Skip to content

We count visits without cookies. May we also use cookies to see how you use the app?

More choices
Ripenly research

What experienced Amazon sellers look for in a niche

Why proven demand, open competition and a better product matter more than finding a market with no sellers.

Published 18 Nov 2026, 14 cited sources

A busy Amazon category isn't automatically a bad bet. Existing sales show that customers are already buying, so the harder question is whether a new brand can earn a share.

Ripenly screens for niches where established demand exists, smaller listings appear to be making sales, and the first page shows room to scale and no saturation. This page lays out the reasoning, the sellers who have publicly discussed the same signals, and where that evidence stops.

The method

Ripenly's method is called Low-Hanging Fruit. Its picture is a street where big chains prove people come to eat, and small places doing well prove there's room for one more.

On Amazon the chains are big brands and Amazon's own listings, and the small places are FBA sellers with modest review counts. The method looks for two kinds of them on the same first page.

  • Entry signal: at least two FBA listings with only a few reviews that already make steady monthly sales. At the Safe level they must also have been on sale for months.
  • Scale signal: at least two more FBA listings that started small and now make serious monthly sales, with a few hundred reviews at most.
  • Market check: skip pages crowded with well-reviewed listings that still sell little.
  • How much proof to ask for should change with your business, product and marketplace. On Pro you choose Safe, Standard or Bold.

Looking for both signals inside one niche is what sets the method apart. None of the sources below prescribes that exact structure.

Seven principles

We compared every source against seven ideas the method rests on.

  1. P1Look for reasons to qualify a niche before rejecting it.
  2. P2Treat established competitors and strong total sales as proof of demand, not a veto.
  3. P3Check whether low-review listings from other sellers already make real sales.
  4. P4Look at early entry and long-term scale, not only search volume.
  5. P5Tell a real opening apart from saturation, or from strong incumbents with weak sales.
  6. P6Compete with a better product, listing or position, or a barrier others won't cross.
  7. P7Match how much proof you ask for to your money, category, marketplace, price and risk.

Evidence by seller

"Strong" means a source directly supports one of the principles. It never means approval of the method, a checked revenue claim or an endorsement of Ripenly.

  • Greg Mercer

    Strong matchR1

    Founder of Jungle Scout, writing about his own product screening.

    Where it matches
    Doesn't let one dominant brand rule a product out. He checks demand and whether lower-review listings manage to rank, and reads a low-review listing that sells as a good sign.
    Where it differs
    More cautious than the method when the top listings have a huge review lead, and he doesn't use paired entry and scale groups.
  • Brandon Young

    Strong matchR2, R3

    Private-label seller and Data Dive co-founder; his sales figures are self-reported.

    Where it matches
    Argues a crowded market can still work when existing brands leave a customer need unserved. Heavy review concentration lowers his score instead of ruling a niche out.
    Where it differs
    Uses much richer keyword, ad and margin analysis than a simple screen.
  • Ryan Daniel Moran

    Strong matchR4

    Builds and talks about Amazon product brands, including on his own podcast.

    Where it matches
    Pushes back on hunting for zero competition. A small share of a large market can be worth more when you build a distinct offer.
    Where it differs
    Says little about review counts, or about needing both new and mature sellers to succeed.
  • Kevin King

    Strong matchR5

    Long-time Amazon seller and educator.

    Where it matches
    Looks at how much of the sales the top listings take and prefers markets where sales spread beyond the top few. His example is the top three taking under 40% of conversions. He also values products that are hard to copy.
    Where it differs
    Works from Brand Analytics, conversions and margins rather than review and age groups. The 40% figure is his rule of thumb.
  • Scott Voelker

    Strong matchR6

    Former private-label seller and host of The Amazing Seller.

    Where it matches
    Looks for products with low review counts that still sell, which is close to the method's entry signal.
    Where it differs
    More wary of heavily reviewed leaders, and has no separate scale group.
  • Seth Kniep

    Strong matchR7

    Founder of Just One Dime.

    Where it matches
    Looks for several top competitors with under 100 reviews that already sell well, and mines their negative reviews for improvements.
    Where it differs
    Asks for a different number of listings and has no scale group. Neither approach guarantees a launch.
  • Ronald Bell

    Strong matchR8

    Interviewed about growing his first private-label business.

    Where it matches
    Chose a big category with modest review counts. One or two sellers with about a thousand reviews didn't put him off, but a page full of them would have.
    Where it differs
    One seller's story from 2020, and his results weren't checked independently.
  • Kevin Pak

    Partial matchR9

    Amazon seller and founder of FBA Boss Academy.

    Where it matches
    Prefers evergreen demand and aims for a share of existing sales, with bundles and product improvements.
    Where it differs
    Little direct support for low-review signals or a two-stage screen.
  • JK Beaton

    Partial matchR10

    Runs a home-goods brand described as seven-figure.

    Where it matches
    Picked his first product where price, keyword demand and weak competitors lined up, such as poor reviews or dated listings.
    Where it differs
    Closer to classic weak-competitor research than to welcoming big brands.
  • Carlos Alvarez

    MixedR11, R12

    Long-time Amazon seller and founder of Wizards of Ecom.

    Where it matches
    Stresses differentiated products that are harder to copy.
    Where it differs
    Other posts of his favor near-zero-competition research, which runs against looking at busy markets.
  • Amy Wees

    Partial matchR13, R14

    Amazon seller and product-development educator.

    Where it matches
    Starts from a customer community and its problems, then checks demand and builds a better, defensible product.
    Where it differs
    No clear sign that she tests low-review entrants or separate mature-seller groups.

Where the evidence stops

  • Sellers don't agree on how much competition is too much. Some like big markets, and others steer clear of strong incumbents.
  • No named seller here uses this exact two-signal formula, so similar signals aren't proof that the formula predicts success.
  • Most sources are interviews and self-reported stories, not a survey or a controlled test of launches.
  • Monthly revenue from sales estimates isn't profit. Ads, returns, stock-outs and costs all change the result.

What we claim

Ripenly screens for niches where established demand exists, smaller listings appear to be making sales, and the first page shows room to scale and no saturation. We don't claim that any seller endorses Ripenly, and we don't promise revenue or a time to revenue.

Sources

Dates are shown where the source gives one. Some pages publish their transcripts only in part.

  1. R1Greg Mercer. How I Use Jungle Scout Data to Help My Amazon FBA SuccessJungle Scout, 1 Oct 2015
  2. R2Brandon Young. Amazon sellers: Don't fear competition, find a customer needLinkedIn, 2026
  3. R3Steve Chou, interviewing Brandon Young. The Secret Sauce of Successful Amazon Sellers, episode 465My Wife Quit Her Job
  4. R4Ryan Daniel Moran. 3 Criteria for Choosing Your First Product on Amazon FBACapitalism.com podcast (transcript mirror), 25 Jul 2019
  5. R5Ben Donovan, interviewing Kevin King. The Current Strategies of 8 & 9 Figure Amazon SellersBrand Builder University, 9 Mar 2022
  6. R6Robert Plank, interviewing Scott Voelker. Retail Arbitrage, Online Arbitrage, Private Labeling and E-Commerce, episode 226Robert Plank's podcast, 2017
  7. R7Heneka Watkis-Porter, interviewing Seth Kniep. How to Launch a New Business When All You Have Is a DimeThe Entrepreneurial You, 9 Feb 2021
  8. R8Helium 10, interviewing Ronald Bell. How a Former Paratrooper Went From 0-100K a Month Selling on AmazonHelium 10 podcast, 9 Sep 2020
  9. R9Mina Elias, interviewing Kevin Pak. Why Most Amazon Sellers FailThe Amazon Blueprint, 2024
  10. R10Steve Chou, interviewing JK Beaton. Student Story: Making 7 Figures Selling Farmhouse Home Decor, episode 501My Wife Quit Her Job
  11. R11Amazon Seller School, interviewing Carlos Alvarez. Stand Out on Amazon: Leveraging Technological DifferentiationAmazon Seller School, 7 Aug 2024
  12. R12Carlos Alvarez. Amazon Product Discovery: Beyond SoftwareWizards of Ecom, LinkedIn, 2026
  13. R13Amy Wees. 5 Pro Tips on How To Find The Right Product To Sell on AmazonAmazing at Home, 26 Sep 2022
  14. R14AM/PM Podcast, interviewing Amy Wees. Building Real Brands with Amy Wees: Harnessing AI in Product Development, episode 372AM/PM Podcast, 2023

Independent research notice: The sellers mentioned here are referenced for their publicly available educational content. They have not reviewed, partnered with, or endorsed this website or its software. Amazon and related marks belong to their respective owners.

See qualified niches